This 1957 New Berlin home underwent a full siding replacement after a mix of aging aluminum and vinyl siding began to show inconsistencies in both appearance and performance. The homeowners wanted a more cohesive look with long-term durability. We replaced the existing exterior with James Hardie 6″ lap siding in Iron Gray, added board and batten gables in Pearl Gray, and finished with Arctic White trim to create a clean, low-maintenance exterior built for Wisconsin weather.
Project Specs
- Location: New Berlin, WI
- Home Style: Mid-century ranch (built in 1957)
- Problem: Mixed aluminum and vinyl siding with inconsistent performance and aging appearance
- Solution: James Hardie fiber cement siding replacement
- Color: Iron Gray lap siding with Pearl Gray board and batten gables
- Trim: Arctic White 4″ James Hardie trim
- Accents: Board and batten gable detail, updated trim lines
- Result: Clean, cohesive exterior with improved durability and modern curb appeal
- Certifications: James Hardie Preferred Installer
Project Overview
This New Berlin ranch home, originally built in 1957, had a combination of aluminum and vinyl siding that had been installed over time. While functional, the mixed materials created an inconsistent appearance and did not provide the long-term durability the homeowners were looking for.
The existing siding was fully removed to create a clean starting point for the new exterior. James Hardie fiber cement siding was selected for its ability to handle Wisconsin’s moisture, temperature swings, and freeze-thaw cycles. We installed 6″ lap siding in Iron Gray, giving the home a more modern, uniform look while maintaining its classic ranch proportions.
To enhance the architectural character, the gables were finished with board and batten siding in Pearl Gray. This contrast introduces vertical lines that break up the horizontal layout of the home and add depth without overcomplicating the design.
One of the defining challenges on this New Berlin home was the combination of aluminum and vinyl siding that had been installed at different points over the years. While each material may have worked on its own, the result was an exterior that lacked consistency in both appearance and performance.
Different siding types age differently, colors fade at different rates, profiles don’t always align, and transitions between materials can create weak points for moisture intrusion. Over time, this can lead to a patchwork look that feels disjointed and harder to maintain.
By removing all existing materials and replacing them with a single, unified system using James Hardie fiber cement siding, we were able to create a cohesive exterior with clean lines and consistent performance. The result is not only a more polished appearance, but also an exterior that functions as one complete system rather than a mix of parts.
The exterior was completed with 4″ Arctic White trim, framing windows, corners, and rooflines. The lighter trim color provides clean contrast against the darker siding while tying together the entire exterior.
Projects like this are something we see frequently on homes throughout the New Berlin area. Many houses built in the 1950s and 60s have gone through multiple exterior updates over time, often resulting in a mix of siding materials and inconsistent finishes. Bringing everything back to a single, well-designed system allows the home to look more intentional while improving long-term performance.
Homes in New Berlin are exposed to a wide range of weather conditions throughout the year, including moisture, temperature swings, and repeated freeze-thaw cycles. These conditions can take a toll on older siding materials over time. By installing James Hardie fiber cement siding, the home is now better equipped to handle seasonal changes while maintaining its appearance and structural integrity.
The finished result is a low-maintenance, cohesive exterior that respects the home’s original structure while bringing it up to modern performance and design standards.
FAQs
1. Why replace aluminum and vinyl siding with fiber cement?
Aluminum and vinyl siding can fade, dent, or warp over time. Fiber cement siding offers greater durability, improved appearance, and better long-term performance in climates like Wisconsin.
2.What makes James Hardie siding a good choice for Wisconsin homes?
James Hardie siding is engineered for cold climates and resists moisture, rot, and damage from freeze-thaw cycles, making it well-suited for homes in New Berlin.
3. Why use board and batten on the gables?
Board and batten adds vertical contrast and architectural interest. It helps break up long horizontal lines and creates a more dynamic exterior design.
4.Is Iron Gray a good siding color for resale value?
Yes. Iron Gray is a popular neutral color that works well across many home styles and provides strong contrast with lighter trim, making it appealing to a wide range of homeowners.
5. How much does siding replacement cost in New Berlin?
The cost of siding replacement in New Berlin depends on several factors, including the size of the home, the condition of the existing exterior, and the materials selected. Projects involving full tear-off and replacement,like upgrading from aluminum siding to James Hardie fiber cement,typically fall into a higher investment range due to the durability and long-term performance of the product.
Homes with additional factors such as repairs to underlying materials, trim upgrades, or design changes may also impact the overall cost. While every project is different, homeowners can expect siding replacement to be a significant investment that improves both the appearance and long-term protection of the home.
The best way to determine accurate pricing is through an on-site consultation, where the home can be evaluated and specific recommendations can be made based on your goals and the condition of the exterior.
Glossary
- Fiber Cement Siding: A durable siding material made from cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, designed to resist moisture, rot, and pests.
- Freeze-Thaw Cycle: The repeated freezing and thawing of moisture that can cause expansion and damage in exterior materials not designed for cold climates. materials. Damage to sheathing must be repaired before new siding is installed.
- Board and Batten: A vertical siding style that uses wide boards with narrow strips (battens) covering the seams, creating a dimensional look.
- Shake Siding: Siding designed to mimic the appearance of hand-split cedar shakes, often used in gables or accent areas.
- Lap Siding: Horizontal siding boards installed in an overlapping pattern to improve water shedding and create a traditional exterior appearance.
