Can You Replace Old Leaking Windows Without Replacing the Siding?

Table of Contents

Picture this: a harsh winter storm rattles your house, and you notice a chilling draft sneaking in through your old, leaky windows. The idea of replacing those windows without tearing off the siding seems impossible. But what if I told you that you can replace your windows without touching the siding? This blog post will explain how you can achieve this, saving time, money, and effort while keeping your home warm and dry.

Why Replace Old Leaking Windows?

replace old leaking windows

Energy Efficiency and Cost Savings

Old, leaky windows can significantly impact your home’s energy efficiency. They allow heat to escape during the winter and let in unwanted heat during the summer, causing your heating and cooling systems to work overtime. By replacing these windows, you can improve your home’s insulation, reduce energy bills, and create a more comfortable living environment.

Preventing Further Damage

Leaking windows can lead to more than just higher energy bills. Water intrusion can cause mold growth, rot, and damage to your home’s structure. Addressing the issue promptly by replacing the windows can prevent these problems from escalating, saving you from costly repairs in the future.

Methods to Replace Windows Without Replacing Siding

Cutting Back the Siding

One effective method to replace windows without replacing the siding is to cut back the siding around the window. Here’s how it works:

  • Preparation: Begin by carefully measuring and marking the area around the window that needs to be cut.
  • Cutting the Siding: Using a saw, cut back the siding around the window, ensuring a clean and precise cut.
  • Window Installation: Remove the old window and install the new one, making sure to add all necessary tapes and flashings to prevent leaks.
  • Finishing Touches: Install a trim board over the cut edges of the siding to cover the gap and provide a finished look.

This method allows you to replace the window while keeping the existing siding intact, avoiding the need for a complete siding replacement.

Removing and Reinstalling Siding

If you have vinyl or steel siding, another approach is to remove and reinstall the siding around the window. This method involves the following steps:

  1. Siding Removal: Carefully remove the siding panels around the window. Be gentle to avoid damaging the panels, especially in colder months when vinyl siding can become brittle and prone to cracking.
  2. Window Installation: With the siding removed, replace the old window with the new one, ensuring all necessary flashings and tapes are in place to prevent leaks.
  3. Reinstalling Siding: Once the window is securely installed, reinstall the siding panels. This approach works best in warmer months when the siding is less likely to crack.

While this method requires more effort, it ensures a thorough installation and maintains the appearance of your home’s exterior.

The Best Time for Window Replacement

Warmer Months

Replacing windows without replacing siding is generally easier during warmer months. Vinyl siding, in particular, becomes more flexible in the heat, reducing the risk of cracking. If possible, plan your window replacement project for late spring, summer, or early fall to take advantage of the favorable weather conditions.

Coordinating with Siding Projects

While it’s possible to replace windows without replacing siding, the most effective approach is to coordinate window replacement with a full siding project. This method offers several benefits:

  • Seamless Integration: Replacing windows as part of a siding project ensures a cohesive and seamless look, as both the windows and siding are installed as a system.
  • Enhanced Weatherproofing: By replacing the siding and windows together, you can achieve better weatherproofing and insulation, enhancing your home’s overall energy efficiency.
  • Long-Term Savings: Although it involves a higher initial cost, combining window and siding replacement can save money in the long run by reducing labor costs and ensuring a more durable, long-lasting solution.


replace old leaking windows

Replacing old, leaky windows without replacing the siding is not only possible but can be a practical solution for many homeowners. Whether you choose to cut back the siding or remove and reinstall it, these methods allow you to improve your home’s energy efficiency and prevent further damage without the need for a complete siding overhaul. However, if your budget allows, coordinating window replacement with a full siding project can provide the best results. No matter which approach you choose, addressing your old windows will lead to a warmer, more comfortable, and energy-efficient home.

If you need expert advice or help with your window replacement project, contact Craftsman’s Choice today to discuss your options and get started on improving your home’s efficiency and comfort.

Ben Juncker


When Ben Juncker was sitting in his high school career planning class, siding installer was not on his list of potential career paths. As with most people in the construction industry, certain questionable life choices led to a point where they were wearing a tool belt, working with their hands. His path started just this way and he would not change a thing. Those early years in his business of scraping and clawing their way to profitability and stability, have helped him to build a culture of hard work and perseverance at Craftsman’s Choice. Ben started his company in 1998 and they installed their first James Hardie job in 2000. Since that time Craftsman’s Choice has become one of the nation’s top James Hardie Remodelers. They have won James Hardie’s prestigious President’s Club award every year since it’s inception in 2015.

Google Rating
Based on 161 reviews